guess the map!

edit: solution here in the comments. don’t read the comments if you want to have a guess first. avert your eyes!
_____

what does this map indicate? no cheating/googling! (^_^)

mystery map

previously: guess the population!

(note: comments do not require an email. albatross!)

Advertisements

28 Comments

  1. The British Isles, Sicily, Cyprus, etc. are connected to the mainland and the Black Sea is a lake – this tells us that the map shows a period before the end of the last Ice Age, i.e. before roughly 12,000 years ago. I doubt that the red areas simply show human settlement because there must have been people in Anatolia during the Ice Age. Maybe red shows the areas of spread of a particular paleolithic culture with dark red indicating that culture’s centers and hotbeds. White in the upper portion of the map obviously shows the extent of year-round ice cover. The areas that were submerged once the ice melted are in light yellow.

    Reply

  2. While there are a number of odd things about the geographic distribution of this trait/characteristic/whatever, the one that strikes me as the strangest is that it encompasses Israel and possibly Lebanon.
    I’m going to guess that this trait/etc. is something genetic, and NOT something cultural, historic or linguistic.

    Peter

    Reply

  3. @peter – “I’m going to guess that this trait/etc. is something genetic, and NOT something cultural, historic or linguistic.”

    well, it’s sorta genetic, but not in the sense you’re thinking of.

    i’ll offer a clue: it’s a population. (^_^)

    (edit: or i guess you could say “population/culture.” depends on how you like to think about these things.)

    Reply

  4. It’s the maximum extant of one of those paleolithic stone cultures….don’t remember which one.

    Reply

  5. It’s the cavemen who really liked big bottoms, and they cannot lie, that a brother can’t deny, that when a girl walks in with an itty-bitty thing, they get sprung! (look at their carvings for clarification)

    Reply

  6. It’s interesting that modern europeans don’t seem to be descended primarily from these people though (the Aurignacians) but rather 50% from middle-eastern neolithic farmers and 50% from siberian hunter-gatherers who ranged from france to the bering straits. Although you could just tell that from looking at most people. Or maybe that’s not the exact scenario; back to the books!!

    Reply

  7. Per capita wine consumption ( or production?) that’s why the Muslim countries aren’t included despite lots of grapes

    Reply

  8. ok! and the solution IS…

    ***SPOILERS***

    …the distribution of the aurignacian or cro-magnon culture [see map with labels here]!

    a virtual pat on the back to naturalismo and spaghetti meatball (now i’m hungry…) who got it right! and to glossy for displaying some excellent map reading/reasoning skillz. (^_^)

    “something to do with the neolithic” is an interesting guess, i think, ’cause it sure looks like it could be something to do with the neolithic. which is interesting, i think.

    A for Effort for “feral cats” — very, very close! (~_^)

    Reply

  9. This is bullshit, why would it be spread all over Europe and then that isolated spot in Israel? Someone has been faking evidence.

    Reply

  10. It is the presence of Aurignacian culture in the Levant that makes the distribution appear Neolithic as there is evidence linking the Cardial to the Levant (the Byblos culture.) The Cardial did not, however, extend so far inland.

    Nonetheless in lithics as an craniometry, typology has its problems as well as its genuine usefulness and different authors have slightly different opinions as to what to include in the Aurignacian culture – for example, some people identify an Aurignacian presence in the Caucasus region, though this is disputed. The discontinuity shown on the map may reflect an absence of evidence from ie. Asia Minor, else it may be an artifact of the subjective judgement of different authorities as to what is truly Aurignacian, or simply Aurignacian-like. A third possibility is the use of sailing craft by Europeoid people living around the Mediterranean during the Early Upper Paleolithic .

    Reply

  11. Yeah right, the Cro Magnons sailed around Asia Minor so they could live in THE ONLY DEMOCRACY IN THE MIDDLE EAST! How credulous are you?

    Reply

  12. Of course those hot spots are not necessarily areas of greater population they may be only areas of more favorable preservation, but still as I look at the map I must wonder , “What’s wrong with Portugal?”. Is it because Portugal is particularly inhospitable?

    I just finished reading a novel about the Peninsula War fought in Portugal. It sounded like a wasteland but that was after the Brits had had a scorched earth policy and the French burnt, pillaged, and destroyed what little was left. But 41,000 years ago what would have kept the Cro-Magnon from spreading to the Atlantic coast? No Alps, no ice.

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Greying Wanderer Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s